AM Cost Calculator Worked Example: When Is a $150 Process Change Worth It?

·

A supplier offers an extra process-control step for $150 per build. Your last build cost $1,800 and delivered 18 acceptable parts from 20 starts. One more good part sounds promising. Is one enough?

Cost per accepted part is $100 for the baseline, $102.63 if the new process delivers 19 parts and $97.50 if it delivers all 20.
At 19 accepted parts the extra step still costs $2.63 more per good part. At 20 it saves $2.50.

Put both quotes on the same basis

This example uses illustrative US dollars. Assume the same geometry, 20 starts, the same acceptance criteria and demand for all 20 parts. The baseline $1,800 includes the print and all downstream work through final inspection. The proposed $150 is the entire incremental batch cost. Both totals include spending on rejected pieces. There is no salvage credit.

ScenarioTotal batch costAccepted partsCost per accepted part
Current route$1,80018$100.00
Extra step, one part recovered$1,95019$102.63
Extra step, two parts recovered$1,95020$97.50

The break-even threshold is 19.5 accepted parts

Divide the new batch cost by the current $100 per accepted part. On a single build you need 20 good parts to beat today’s cost. Across many identical builds, 19.5 accepted per build on average would tie it. If demand stops at 18 per build and surplus cannot be used, recovering extra pieces creates no immediate unit-cost saving on the 18 delivered.

Run it with your own build

Take the entire-build estimate from the AM Cost Calculator. Add actual downstream charges that your estimate excludes, such as an external machining invoice or a final inspection charge. Count each cost once. Divide by the final accepted quantity from the same batch. Repeat for the proposed route using its extra cost and a realistic range of yields.

Before approving the change, ask which rejection mode it prevents. If one of the two losses occurred during machining and the proposed step can recover only the other one, even a perfect fix for that failure mode leaves this batch at $102.63 per accepted part.

Comments

Leave a Reply